Records, privacy and banned lists

Can a bar keep a fake ID?

Published November 3, 2026 · 16 sources linked

The short answer

Only where state law allows it, subject to its conditions. California, Colorado, Georgia, Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota and North Dakota let staff keep an ID they believe is fake, with steps such as a receipt for the guest and handing the card to the police within a set time. Utah allows a hold only until the police arrive, if they can come within 30 minutes, and Maine, New Hampshire, North Carolina and Wisconsin protect staff from liability for a reasonable hold while they check an ID, which is not a power to keep it.

Fake ID rules at a glance

Staff may keep the card: California, Colorado, Georgia, Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota and North Dakota
When the police get it: 24 hours in California, Indiana, Iowa and Minnesota; North Dakota, 24 hours to notify them; Colorado, 72 hours; Georgia, a call to the police at once
A hold until the police arrive: Utah, and only if they can come within 30 minutes
A state not named here: Not a sign that its law allows keeping the card

AgeShield ID Scanner

A forgery check before anyone decides

Every mode checks a US or Canadian license or state ID barcode for signs of forgery when the barcode is scanned. A flag calls for a closer look. What happens to the card stays the venue's call under its state's law.

See what a flag means Start your 14-day free trial

Why keeping a fake ID is a state law question

Turning a guest away and keeping their card are two separate steps. States that allow confiscation specify who can take the card, on what grounds and what follows.

The laws below are about IDs that staff believe are false or altered. A genuine card shown by someone else is covered in borrowed IDs at the door; Indiana, Iowa and Georgia cover it in the same sections.

States that let staff keep a fake ID

Alcohol laws that let a licensee or its staff keep a fake ID

State	When staff may keep it	What follows	Source
California	A licensee or employee may seize an ID that is false or shows the person is under 21.	The person gets a receipt and the ID goes to the local police within 24 hours. A decision not to seize creates no civil or criminal liability.	Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code 25659
Colorado	A licensee or employee with reasonable cause to believe a person under 21 is showing fraudulent proof of age to get alcohol may confiscate it, if possible.	It goes to state or local police within 72 hours; failing to confiscate or hand it over is not a crime. Staff acting in good faith are immune from liability unless they act willfully or wantonly.	C.R.S. 44-3-901(6)(a)
Georgia	A retailer or staff member handed a driver's license that appears falsified, belongs to someone else or shows the holder is under 21 may seize and keep it, or write down the name, address and license number instead.	Either way, staff summon a law enforcement officer immediately afterwards.	O.C.G.A. 3-3-23(i)
Indiana	Staff who have had alcohol server training may keep an ID shown to buy alcohol when they reasonably believe it was altered or falsified, or was not issued to the person who showed it.	A receipt stating the date and hour, then the ID and a written statement to the police within 24 hours. Keeping it this way carries no liability, but using force to get it is not covered.	IC 7.1-5-7-4.5
Iowa	A retail alcohol licensee or employee may keep a driver's license or nonoperator's ID card offered to buy alcohol when they have a reasonable belief, based on factual evidence, that it is altered or falsified or belongs to another person.	A receipt with the date and hour, then the card and a written report to the city or county police within 24 hours. No prosecution or civil liability for keeping and delivering it, but civil liability for unreasonable force remains.	Iowa Code 123.48
Minnesota	A licensed retailer or municipal liquor store may seize an ID when it has reasonable grounds to believe the ID was altered or falsified or is being used to break any law.	It goes to a law enforcement agency within 24 hours.	Minn. Stat. 340A.503, subd. 6
North Dakota	A licensed retailer or employee may seize an ID shown as proof of age when they reasonably believe it was altered or falsified or is being used to get alcohol unlawfully.	Within 24 hours the retailer notifies the police, who take the ID within 24 hours of the notice.	N.D.C.C. 5-01-08.3

State: California
When staff may keep it: A licensee or employee may seize an ID that is false or shows the person is under 21.
What follows: The person gets a receipt and the ID goes to the local police within 24 hours. A decision not to seize creates no civil or criminal liability.
Source: Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code 25659

State: Colorado
When staff may keep it: A licensee or employee with reasonable cause to believe a person under 21 is showing fraudulent proof of age to get alcohol may confiscate it, if possible.
What follows: It goes to state or local police within 72 hours; failing to confiscate or hand it over is not a crime. Staff acting in good faith are immune from liability unless they act willfully or wantonly.
Source: C.R.S. 44-3-901(6)(a)

State: Georgia
When staff may keep it: A retailer or staff member handed a driver's license that appears falsified, belongs to someone else or shows the holder is under 21 may seize and keep it, or write down the name, address and license number instead.
What follows: Either way, staff summon a law enforcement officer immediately afterwards.
Source: O.C.G.A. 3-3-23(i)

State: Indiana
When staff may keep it: Staff who have had alcohol server training may keep an ID shown to buy alcohol when they reasonably believe it was altered or falsified, or was not issued to the person who showed it.
What follows: A receipt stating the date and hour, then the ID and a written statement to the police within 24 hours. Keeping it this way carries no liability, but using force to get it is not covered.
Source: IC 7.1-5-7-4.5

State: Iowa
When staff may keep it: A retail alcohol licensee or employee may keep a driver's license or nonoperator's ID card offered to buy alcohol when they have a reasonable belief, based on factual evidence, that it is altered or falsified or belongs to another person.
What follows: A receipt with the date and hour, then the card and a written report to the city or county police within 24 hours. No prosecution or civil liability for keeping and delivering it, but civil liability for unreasonable force remains.
Source: Iowa Code 123.48

State: Minnesota
When staff may keep it: A licensed retailer or municipal liquor store may seize an ID when it has reasonable grounds to believe the ID was altered or falsified or is being used to break any law.
What follows: It goes to a law enforcement agency within 24 hours.
Source: Minn. Stat. 340A.503, subd. 6

State: North Dakota
When staff may keep it: A licensed retailer or employee may seize an ID shown as proof of age when they reasonably believe it was altered or falsified or is being used to get alcohol unlawfully.
What follows: Within 24 hours the retailer notifies the police, who take the ID within 24 hours of the notice.
Source: N.D.C.C. 5-01-08.3

Each law says staff may keep the card, and none of them requires it.

California's alcohol regulator turns the rule into a routine: refuse the sale, then give the ID back or seize it, depending on the company's policy. Its page describes a receipt in three copies: one for the guest, one attached to the ID and one kept with notes on who, what, when, where and why.

California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, Checking Identification

Holding a card while staff check it

Five other states address brief holds. Only Utah's rule has a clock on it.

Laws on holding an ID for a short time

State	What the law says	Source
Utah	At a bar, tavern, restaurant or off-premise beer retailer, when staff find an ID is fake, or the state's electronic verification program finds it fake, staff may temporarily confiscate a physical ID and call the police to verify it. If the police cannot come within 30 minutes, staff return the ID immediately; if they can, staff may keep control of it until they arrive.	Utah Code 32B-1-407(7)
Maine	A licensee is not liable for retaining an ID shown as proof of age for a reasonable length of time in a good faith effort to determine the person's age, provided staff tell the person why they are holding it.	28-A M.R.S. 2516(2)
New Hampshire	No civil liability for retaining proof of age for a reasonable length of time in a good faith effort to determine age or to notify the police of a suspected violation of law.	RSA 507-F:7, II
North Carolina	No civil liability for holding a customer's ID for a reasonable length of time in a good faith attempt to determine whether they are of legal age, provided staff tell the customer the reason.	N.C.G.S. 18B-129(b)
Wisconsin	No civil liability for retaining a document shown as proof of age for a reasonable length of time in a good faith effort to determine whether the person is underage or to report a suspected false ID offense to the police.	Wis. Stat. 125.039

State: Utah
What the law says: At a bar, tavern, restaurant or off-premise beer retailer, when staff find an ID is fake, or the state's electronic verification program finds it fake, staff may temporarily confiscate a physical ID and call the police to verify it. If the police cannot come within 30 minutes, staff return the ID immediately; if they can, staff may keep control of it until they arrive.
Source: Utah Code 32B-1-407(7)

State: Maine
What the law says: A licensee is not liable for retaining an ID shown as proof of age for a reasonable length of time in a good faith effort to determine the person's age, provided staff tell the person why they are holding it.
Source: 28-A M.R.S. 2516(2)

State: New Hampshire
What the law says: No civil liability for retaining proof of age for a reasonable length of time in a good faith effort to determine age or to notify the police of a suspected violation of law.
Source: RSA 507-F:7, II

State: North Carolina
What the law says: No civil liability for holding a customer's ID for a reasonable length of time in a good faith attempt to determine whether they are of legal age, provided staff tell the customer the reason.
Source: N.C.G.S. 18B-129(b)

State: Wisconsin
What the law says: No civil liability for retaining a document shown as proof of age for a reasonable length of time in a good faith effort to determine whether the person is underage or to report a suspected false ID offense to the police.
Source: Wis. Stat. 125.039

The last four provide liability protection, not seizure authority. New Hampshire's and Wisconsin's also cover a hold while staff notify the police.

Where the law speaks of refusing or reporting

Some alcohol laws address a fake ID without giving staff a power to keep it. Alaska's rules require staff who have reason to believe an ID is fraudulent to refuse the person entry and service. Idaho's rules say that when an ID shown to staff appears mutilated, altered or fraudulent, they contact law enforcement or refuse service, or both; IDs lost or voluntarily surrendered go to the state's alcohol agency or the police within 15 days. In Michigan, a licensee with reason to believe a minor used a fraudulent ID to buy alcohol must file a police report, and present the ID with it if the licensee has it.

Omission from these tables does not mean confiscation is allowed. Each state guide covers that state's ID law, and a written door policy is where a venue can settle what staff do with a card they doubt.

3 AAC 305.800(a)IDAPA 11.05.01.021.02 MCL 436.1903(2)

Where a scan fits

On a US or Canadian license or state ID, every AgeShield scan checks the barcode for signs of forgery, in every scan mode. A CHECK FAILED result tells staff to look closer. It is not proof on its own that an ID is fake, and staff make the call.

Every scan leaves a visit record of who scanned, when, the result and what staff decided, which can help with California's receipt notes or Indiana's written statement. It holds no license number for Georgia's written note, because AgeShield never stores the full ID number.

Whatever happens to the card, AgeShield's guidance is never to tell a guest their ID is fake because of a scan result, and to say staff cannot accept the ID instead. How to refuse entry at a bar has more on the wording.

Four emails a year

What changed in ID law, before it takes effect

Many state rules on IDs and age checks take effect on January 1 or July 1. Each quarter we send one short summary of the changes we found, with the source for every line, starting with the states you pick.

Common questions

Can a bouncer take your fake ID?

In some states. California, Colorado, Georgia, Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota and North Dakota let a licensee or its staff keep an ID they believe is fake, each with its own steps, such as a receipt and handing the card to the police. Utah allows a hold only until the police arrive, if they can come within 30 minutes.

Does a bar have to confiscate a fake ID?

None of the laws covered here requires it. Each says staff may keep the card. California's adds that not seizing one creates no liability, and Colorado's that failing to confiscate one is not a crime. What these laws require comes after a card is taken, such as the receipt and the hand-over to the police. Georgia's call to the police applies whether staff keep the card or write down its details.

Do you get your ID back if a bar keeps it?

Indiana's and Iowa's laws say the police release the card to the person it was issued to if they do not open an investigation or find probable cause. In Utah, staff return it immediately if the police cannot come within 30 minutes.

Can a bar keep an ID because a scan flagged it?

The laws above turn on what staff believe about the card, and Utah's also counts a finding by the electronic verification program set up under its law. An AgeShield CHECK FAILED result tells staff to look closer and is not proof on its own that an ID is fake.

Sources

This page is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal advice. We research each rule and link its source, so you can check it against your own venue. Questions are welcome at support@ageshield.bar.

Still unsure what your state says about fake IDs?

Tell us what type of venue you run and we'll point you to the published rules we know of that may apply.

Ask about fake IDs Start your 14-day free trial